Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Casey's New Buffalo

Casey’s offers casual fine dining that includes hand-cut steaks, fresh seafood, signature burgers and sandwiches and creative salad options. We are focused on bringing you the highest quality food, sourced locally whenever possible. We have the largest selection of craft beers on tap in Harbor Country, signature cocktails and a carefully crafted wine list.

Casey’s is reminiscent of a traditional Chicago-style grill, with its antique tin ceiling, historic Art Deco bar and hardwood floor, but includes some decorative influences from its lakeside location. There are plenty of TV's, so you won't miss the big game and we host live entertainment every weekend.

When the weather’s fine, eat and drink in Casey’s Back Yard, a delightful landscaped patio, featuring our outdoor Ice House bar (originally a building used to store ice cut from the lake in the winter). On weekends, our customers often tarry after dinner to enjoy live music with friends, old and new.